When will Power Costs Exceed Labors Costs in the Data Center

Reading this post about Eco-friendly Skies brings up the point that energy costs exceed labors costs for the airline industry. It may take a while for the Data Center to reach this point, or it may depend on how you count your staff. If you count only the staff to run the physical infrastructure of the data center, this point may have already reached for many. Maybe this is a way to get the attention of executives how big electricity bills are.

On my flight out to Seattle to research Boeing's advances, I pause as I leave the plane to ask the pilot if flying any differently could reduce the emission of greenhouse gases. He sets me straight. "It's not about greenhouse gases," he says. "It's all about fuel burn." From 2000 to 2007, the price of aviation fuel in the U.S. swelled by 115.6 percent, and fuel has topped labor as the number-one operating cost of the airline industry. Airlines, always concerned about fuel costs, are now obsessed with them. The nearest-term way airlines can reduce this expense (and reduce their greenhouse-gas emissions in the process) is to change how planes are flown.

Also the obsession with performance vs. efficiency is illustrated by this Boeing story.  Wouldn't it be great if server vendors picked up the Airbus/Boeing practice of being accountable for the energy efficiency promised?  When the 787 ships, if the customers don't achieve the promised energy efficiency, then Boeing is forced to account for the lack of efficiency.

Jeff Hawk, the Boeing Environment and Certification director who has worked on the 787 since 2002. He says that before the Dreamliner, Boeing had been planning to build a faster plane. He pulls out an off-white model of the original design, the Sonic Cruiser, which looks like a cousin to the Concorde. The Sonic Cruiser, streamlined like a barracuda, was to fly at the edge of the speed of sound.

"On a transatlantic flight, it would save about an hour or two," Hawk says. "It flew 20 percent faster but produced the same amount of fuel burn." The design concept crumbled when the airline industry was blindsided by the September 11 attacks in 2001. Passengers avoided the skies, and the industry lost $25 billion in just three years. Meanwhile, fuel prices crept upward and fuel efficiency became a top priority. Boeing decided to divert technologies being used to build a faster plane into building a more fuel-efficient one. Composite material planned for the Sonic Cruisers—carbon-fiber-reinforced plastic that's 70 percent the weight of aluminum—was carried over to the 787.

Engineers squeezed every efficiency they could from the airplane's classic shape. Among other tricks, they created a longer and thinner wing to generate more lift and less drag. As one part of the airplane became more fuel-efficient, so did the next. "If you have a low-drag airplane, you can use a much more efficient engine," Hawk explains. "That less-powerful engine is smaller. It's lighter too. A smaller engine means less drag. Instead of 20 percent faster, we were 20 percent more fuel-efficient." That efficiency has been a major selling point. Boeing has pre-sold 738 airplanes to 51 customers, making it the most successful release of a commercial jet in the company's history. It's also good for global warming, Boeing says, because 20 percent less fuel burn translates into 20 percent less greenhouse gas produced.

Read more

Greenwashing, Clorox Goes Green, Sierra Club Approves the Use of their Logo

Greenwashing is normally a bad term for any company/product. But, Clorox may be able to use this term for their Green Works products. Clorox is transforming their company to be Green.  They purchased Burt's Bee products.

Today, the couple’s quirky enterprise is owned by the Clorox Company, a consumer products giant best known for making bleach, which bought it for $913 million in November. Clorox plans to turn Burt’s Bees into a mainstream American brand sold in big-box stores like Wal-Mart. Along the way, Clorox executives say, they plan to learn from unusual business practices at Burt’s Bees — many centered on environmental sustainability. Clorox, the company promises, is going green.

The Treehugger Blog even writes favorably about this move,and has the endorsement from the Sierra Club.

The bottle itself has a couple of things that make what's on the outside almost as compelling as the cleaner inside. First of all, the Sierra Club (whose Conservation Director, Greg Haegele, blogs here at TreeHugger) will endorse the product by placing their logo on the label. "We'll definitely have some folks who are surprised by this decision, but also people who are pretty excited about it," said Sierra Club spokeswoman Orli Cotel. "We are supporting Green Works in hopes that more people will have access to these kinds of products, some of which aren't even available in the middle of the country."

The Sierra Club approved the use of their logo as part of the Green Works brand after it asked several of its volunteer committees to review the cleaners; it's the first time the non-profit has given its blessing to a household cleaning product. "We hope we are transforming the marketplace by doing this," said Sierra Club executive director Carl Pope. "These products are clean, they're green, they're not going to hurt you, and they're not going to hurt the environment."

This brings us to one of the other eyebrow-raisers: Clorox cheerfully lists the ingredients for Green Works on the label -- something it doesn't do for its conventional cleaners -- and also prominently displays the Clorox logo. They're hoping that the equation of "trusted brand (and the proven efficacy that comes with it) + transparency = success," and Joel Makower thinks it'll be a pretty big deal: "This is a kind of watershed moment. We finally have major consumer companies taking the green marketplace seriously, and not as an afterthought." (He also did some consulting on the project).

The Green momentum continues to build.  There are interesting lessons to be learned by what Clorox has done.  Buying Green expertise to change the mindset in the company, creating a critical mass of people who think sustainability and green. Working with a non-profit and consumers to get feedback on their Green initiative.  And the hope that, Trusted Brand + transparency  = success.

Read more

50 Green Cities

Popular Science has an article about the 50 Greenest cities in the USA. It was interesting what they highlighted as green efforts by different cities.

CASE STUDY: Grass Power
Boston has preliminary plans for a plant that would turn 50,000 tons of fall color into power and fertilizer. The facility would first separate yard clippings into grass and leaves. Anaerobic bacteria feeding on the grass would make enough methane to power at least 1.5 megawatts’ worth of generators, while heat and agitation would hasten the breakdown of leaves and twigs into compost.

CATEGORY LEADER: Electricity
Much of the wet Pacific Northwest draws its energy from hydroelectric dams. But Eugene draws an additional 9 percent of its municipal electricity from wind farms. It also buys back excess power from residents who install solar panel

See how Chicago's power plants produce twice the energy with a third the carbon, here.

CASE STUDY: Green Concrete
Fly ash, a by-product of coal-burning power plants, usually ends up in landfills. Researchers at the University of Colorado Denver found a way to reuse this industrial by-product. They add it at concentrations of about 20 percent to a new green concrete mix. The addition of fly ash also reduces the amount of sulfur- and carbon-spewing concrete production needed to finish a job. The mayor has signed an executive order requiring the use of green concrete in new city projects, and a $550-million infrastructure bond makes demand for the mix likely to grow.

CATEGORY LEADER: Recycling and green perspective
Lexingtonians recycle everything from surplus electronics to scrap metal, and they listed the environment as their third most important concern (behind only employment and public safety)—the highest ranking in our survey. 

Read more

Can you Feel the Energy Efficiency?

I was in a late night IM session with Microsoft's Lewis Curtis and we were discussing Power Management.  In my past life as a Microsoft employee, one of my jobs was program manager and software evangelist for Windows 2000 power management feature so I know the features, and even though Windows Vista and Windows Server 2008 have improved their power management capabilities. I wonder if they're still missing the target.

The problem is if you save let's say 50% of your energy consumption on your laptop because it sleeps/hibernates more aggressively, does the user feel like they are saving energy? The Toyota Prius works, because the Dashboard gives you real time feedback on how efficient you are. As a Prius driver you can make a conscious decision on how energy efficient you are.

So, is what is needed is an energy efficiency user interface?  Addressing the issue of "Can you feel the energy efficiency?"

On the desktop, the one company who I think may do this would be Apple. They have ability to develop the HW, modify the OS, make BIOS changes, and the hardest part make sure the drivers work in the right way. Plus Steve Jobs will do something if he thinks it feels right. It's not logical, but it sells the user experience.

What do you think the UI should be for the Data Center?  Is it Power Usage Effectiveness, PUE? Do the users care about PUE, or do they need something else because PUE works for total data center operations? I want to discuss this with a few who have energy monitoring in data centers to get their opinions.

OK, a few confessions came up when I was writing this.

  1. I worked on the Mac Portable while at Apple. (PC World rated the Macintosh Portable as the seventeenth worst tech product of all time)
  2. I don't own a Prius.  But, I only drive 3,000 miles a year for the past 15 years.  So, my environmental impact would be bigger if I bought a Prius and didn't drive it much.
  3. In hindsight, I could have done a much better job on Win2K power management features.
  4. I need to work on my blog post for greenest thing I've done.
Read more

NetworkWorld article on Green Grid Technical Forum - Wanted: Energy Efficient Standards

NetworkWorld attended the Green Grid Technical forum and wrote an article titled, Wanted: Energy efficient standards for data centers.

The article has customer interviews from Allstate, ADP, Enterprise Rent-A-Car integrated, but I cant' tell if the interviews were done at the Green Grid Technical Forum, or they are from previous interviews. (Appended Feb 9, 2008, there were presentations by these companies at the Forum)

The only part I can find about the Forum is

A number of speakers at the Green Grid event said user education was the first challenge to greening their data centers. Educating internal users -- even IT staff such as application developers -- and computer component vendors of the need to focus on data center efficiency instead of raw speed and power were two such challenges.

Read more