Google Mail/Apps ups SLA, removes schedule downtime allowance

Data Centers and uptime is assumed.  Service Level Agreements (SLA) are made between groups.  But, many times there are exceptions for planned maintenance/downtime vs. unplanned downtime when calculating SLA.

InformationWeek reports on Google Apps/Gmail's change to this common practice.

Google Promises No Planned Downtime

A new service level agreement (SLA) for Google Apps customers strives to make Google's cloud as reliable as dial tone.

By Thomas ClaburnInformationWeek
January 14, 2011 02:42 PM

Google has changed its service level agreement for paid versions of Google Apps, its suite of online applications. The goal, says Google Enterprise product management director Matt Glotzbach, is to deliver service that's as reliable as telephone dial tone.

For today's mobile generation, who may lack experience with landlines, let it suffice to say that dial tone under Ma Bell was very, very reliable. Not sunrise reliable but chances were if you didn't hear a dial tone when you picked up a handset, the phone was disconnected from the wall.

Google is taking a leadership position.

But with millions of enterprise customers, Google aims to become more reliable. As a sign of its commitment, the company has disavowed planned downtime. "Unlike most providers, we don't plan for our users to be down, even when we're upgrading our services or maintaining our systems," wrote Glotzbach in a blog post. "For that reason, we're removing the SLA clause that allows for scheduled downtime."

Glotzbach says Google is the first major cloud service provider to make that pledge.

In Google's blog post they call out the competition.

Gmail: 99.984%
In 2010, Gmail was available 99.984 percent of the time, for both business and consumer users. 99.984 percent translates to seven minutes of downtime per month over the last year. That seven-minute average represents the accumulation of small delays of a few seconds, and most people experienced no issues at all. For those few who were disrupted for a longer period of time, we're very sorry, and Google Apps for Business customers received compensation where appropriate. We're particularly pleased with this level of reliability since it was accomplished without any planned downtime while launching 30 new features and adding tens of millions of active users.
Seven minutes of downtime compares very favorably with on-premises email, which is subject to much higher rates of interruption that hurt employee productivity. The latest research from the Radicati Group found that on-premises email averaged 3.8 hours of downtime per month. In comparison to Radicati's metrics for on-premises email, our calculations suggest that Gmail is 32 times more reliable than the average email system, and 46 times more available than Microsoft Exchange®.1

Fortunately Microsoft Exchange® customers can still benefit from the reliability of Gmail withGoogle Message Continuity. Comparable data for Microsoft BPOS® is unavailable, thoughtheir service notifications show 113 incidents in 2010: 74 unplanned outages, and 33 days with planned downtime.

You may be thinking I can't do this in my data center.  And you are right you can't.  This solution requires geo redundancy between data centers.  For a bit on some of Google's approach check out this Google presentation at Stanford University.

Google – A study in Scalability and A little systems horse sense

By ksankar

16 Votes

Google’s Jeff Dean did an excellent talk at Stanford as part of EE380 – it is worth one’s time to listen. Very informative, instructive and innovative. As I listened, I jotted a few quick notes.

  • Interesting comparison of the scale in search from 1999 to 2010
    • Docs and queries are up 1000X, while the query latency has decreased 5X
    • Interesting to hear that in 1999 they used to update a web page store in a month or two, but now it is reduced 50000X to seconds!
  • They have had 7 significant revisions in 11 years
  • Trivia : They encounter very expensive queries for example “circle of death” requires ~30GB of I/O
  • Trivia : In 2004, they did a rethink and refreshed the systems infrastructure from scratch
  • He discussed a little about encodings – informative discussion on Byte aligned variable length & group encoding schemes << I have to try it out …
  • Trivia : They have had long distance links failure by wild dogs, sharks, dead horses and (in Oregon) drunken hunters !

The presentation referenced is by Jeff Dean.

image

Read more

Last Month of traffic to Top 5 data center construction companies post, shows Morgan Stanley and Kaiser Permanente

Took a look at the last month, Dec 13 – Jan 12, 2011 traffic to my Top 5 Data Center Construction companies post. 

Roughly 400 hits through Google search. 

Two companies popped up with relatively high traffic.  Morgan Stanley and Kaiser Permanente.

Good chance someone in these companies is looking for data center construction and design.

Read more

Data Center Wingman, who has your back? One of the best Olivier Sanche

Today a group of people are getting together to raise money in memory of Olivier Sanche for his daughter Emilie's college fund.

The Memorial Fun that has been set up at Wells Fargo Bank under the Olivier Sanche Memorial Fund, account #3165058052. The fund is open until January 23rd, the week following the fund proceeds will be presented to Olivier's family towards Emilie's future education.

Olivier and I spent a lot of time together and one of the ways you could describe our relationship is we were wingman for each other.

"The wingman is absolutely indispensable. I look after the wingman. The wingman looks after me. It's another set of eyes protecting you. That's the defensive part.


"Offensively, it gives you a lot more firepower. We work together. We fight together. The wingman knows what his responsibilities are and knows what mine are. Wars are not won by individuals. They're won by teams."
Today, the strategy of having a good wingman is still relevant, but its application reaches far beyond the arena of aerial assault. When fighter pilots lift off into the great expanses of the sky, they may not know what threats lie beyond the horizon. Similarly, with each new day, we have no idea what lies ahead.


The common denominator is that daily challenges are conquered by responsible choices, and creating a culture of responsible choices is reinforced by the presence of a good wingman. In the spirit of the Gabreski quote, "personal battles are not won by individuals; they are won by the reinforcement of good wingmen."

We had each others back and watched out for each other in the data center industry.  Olivier was a wingman I could count on that had integrity that was never questioned.  It is a complex task to green the data center.  Much more than simply getting LEED points.

The challenge, like a thousand-piece puzzle, is that it can sometimes be more difficult than it first appears. The path of least resistance shouts for us to do nothing while a fellow Airman makes a life or career-threatening decision; however, accepting the challenge of being a comrade in arms is a daily whisper for us to courageously be involved. The moral courage to do the right thing is more than just ornamented words; it is the foundation of our Air Force Core Values: Integrity First.

I miss Oliver as a wingman, but any person who uses the concept of a wingman wants more than one wingman/wingwoman.

Who has your back?

Read more

How big are Russian Data Centers?

A question I got from a friend is how big are Russian Data Centers?  As Facebook pointed out Facebook traffic is almost non-existent given they are not an approved site for the country.  Huh?

Here is post on Facebook’s traffic.

Paul Butler on Monday, December 13, 2010 at 5:16pm

Visualizing data is like photography. Instead of starting with a blank canvas, you manipulate the lens used to present the data from a certain angle.

When the data is the social graph of 500 million people, there are a lot of lenses through which you can view it. One that piqued my curiosity was the locality of friendship. I was interested in seeing how geography and political borders affected where people lived relative to their friends. I wanted a visualization that would show which cities had a lot of friendships between them.

Note how dark Russia and China are.

What are the Russia web sites if Facebook and others are not allowed?

•Yandex=Google Search

•VKontakte=Facebook

•Odnoklassniki=Classmates

•LiveJournal=blogging platform

•RuTube=YouTube

The biggest data center so far in Russia is claimed to be a 8MW data center as reported by Data Center Dynamics, Yevgeniy Sverdlik.

MegaFon launches new data center in Russia

Telecom says the 8MW data center is the largest of its kind in Russia, offering colocaiton, managed hosting and Internet services out of six 4,300-sq-ft data halls

Published 12th October, 2010 by Yevgeniy Sverdlik

MegaFon data center in Samara

Russian telecommunications company MegaFon has launched what it says is the largest data center of its caliber in the nation. The 8MW facility in Samara is the first facility of the future “national data center network,” according to a MegaFon news release.
Valeriy Ermakov, chief operations officer at MegaFon, said this was the first time a new state-of-the-art data center of this size was built in Russia for commercial use.

Another Yevgyeniy reports on is a Telecom data center.

Rostelecom embarks on $219m data center build-out in Russia

Telecom will build two new data centers and retrofit existing facilities

Published 24th May, 2010 by DatacenterDynamics

Large Russian telecommunications firm Rostelecom is planning to invest $219m into building new data centers and retrofitting its existing facilities into data centers to begin providing data center services in the country, reported Russian news serviceKommersant. The plan is to make the investment over the next four years.
The company is going to build two new data centers in Moscow and Saint Petersburg metropolitan areas. The Moscow facility is designed to accommodate 3,500 IT racks and the St. Petersburg one will support 500. Rostelecom’s existing facilities can support 399 racks.

Megafon and Rostelcom look like the biggest data center builders, but given 8 MW is the largest so far, we’ll see when Russian breaks the 10 MW mark.

BTW, it does like Dell DCS is a supplier to Yandex.

Brannon boasts that while Google famously makes its own servers, Dell caters to three others from the ‘Search engine top five', hinting that Facebook is also a DCS customer.

Three-s-a-clowd

But, sensing a great business opportunity in hand-me-downs and cheap knock-offs, Dell cunningly decided it would sell on its custom-made designs to smaller outfits, like Russian search engine and portal Yandex, for less cash.

Read more

What could Google do with 111 Eight Ave building? Part 2, change what carrier hotels look like

I wrote last week on What could Google do with 111 Eighth Ave building? A new bargaining chip

Another idea that just popped into my head is Google could turn 111 Eight Ave building into a change agent for the carrier hotels, Internet Exchanges, Peering, and who knows what else they want to drive in the industry.

The current model of carrier hotels are run by private enterprises or a non-profit like AMS-IX.

Vision

AMS-IX: the trusted value creator in quality IP interconnection [1]

Mission

1. To realize the principal, neutral IP interconnection marketplace worldwide

2. To offer world-class quality performance and operate a future proof platform to secure the growth of IP traffic between connected parties

3. Support initiatives for the good of the Internet to ultimately improve end-user experience

Values

  • Neutral
  • Trusted
  • Pragmatic
  • Open
  • Innovative

Equinix is an example of private Internet Exchange site.

When our founders started Equinix, they envisioned a place where the information-driven world could grow and thrive.

As the company looks forward, we remain dedicated to the advancement of the information-driven world. This means that we will:

  • protect and connect our customers’ most valuable information assets;
  • constantly strive to evolve and share our industry insights with our customers;
  • continue to make necessary investments to expand and scale to our customer's needs;
  • act upon industry trends that will affect our business and the businesses of our customers;
  • cultivate a rich interconnected ecosystem of the top networks, carriers, ISPs, and business partners in the world.

What happens when Google takes their money, knowledge, and strategic vision and demonstrate to the rest of the industry the way they want carrier hotels to operate?

Don’t just think of Internet technology, think of different business models as well.  Many ideas have failed because of the business model, not the technology.

Google has 24 Public Peering Exchange Points in Equinix facilities.  The largest amount dedicated to any one company.  Don’t you think 111 Eighth Ave changes the conversations between Equinix and Google?

Google has sponsored projects like Google Fiber for Communities.

Google Fiber for Communities: Next steps

The deadline for responses to our request for information has passed. We will announce our target community or communities by the end of the year. In the meantime please visit fiberforcommunities.com to learn how to take action to improve broadband where you live.

Since we announced our plans to build experimental, ultra high-speed broadband networks, the response has been tremendous. Hundreds of communities and hundreds of thousands of individuals across the country have expressed their interest in the project. We're not going to be able to build in every interested community - our plan is to reach a total of at least 50,000 and potentially up to 500,000 people - but we hope to learn lessons from this experiment that will help improve Internet access everywhere.

We humbly thank each and every community and individual for taking the time to participate. If one message has come through loud and clear, it's this: people across the country are hungry for better and faster Internet access.

Map

This map displays where the responses were concentrated. Each small dot represents a government response, and each large dot represents locations where more than 1,000 residents submitted a nomination. A list of government responses is available here.

Seems natural Google would want to change the Internet Exchanges as well.

Read more