Google's "How Green is the Internet?" videos are up, next is the presentations then analysis

Google pushed up the videos for "How Green is Internet?" yesterday.

Driving the industry forward

Through industry collaboration, we aim to create a more sustainable technology sector and build products and services that benefit the environment. For example, we hosted events in 2009 and 2011 where we discussed with industry peers how we can improve on data center efficiency. In June 2013, we hosted the “How green is the Internet?” summit.

The videos allow you to see the presentations.  The slides will be up soon as well.

The news covered the event with the following posts I pointed to.  So what is next?  Some perspective and analysis.

I got a chance to sit in a media briefing with Urs Hoelzle that supported the media posts.  Sitting next to Urs we chatted before anyone else came in and had a good time following up on some discussions.  

There were bunch of side conversations I had with wholesales data center operators, data center users, technology companies, various support staff many who are friends I hadn't seen for a while and some I saw only 24 hrs ago at 7x24 Exchange in Boca. Jonathan Koomey and I discussed a paper that I will interview him for.  Gary Cook will also be interviewed for the same paper and luckily I was able to get the three of us to chat about the ideas.  I thought Gary and Jonathan knew each other which they did, but they hadn't actually met in person.

The RAW data is there - videos and presentations.  Media reports were made as well.   The vast majority of people will base their opinion of the event on what the media writes.  One excellent insight is George Orwell's comment on writing that I posted.  Knowing someone's motives allows you to understand their perspective

 I give all this background information because I do not think one can 
assess a writer's motives without knowing something of his early 
development.

I didn't get a chance to get the early development background of the media, but sitting in a conf room for an hour watching the questions asked, how they reacted gives a perspective to read their writing.  Can you imagine if when you read a media post you were able to watch the video of the interview side-by-side to watch the interview and read their writing.  When I was at the IBM Impact conference I got a more extended view of the media process.

Some of the things I've figured out I have written down to post, but after reading them, the ideas are esotreric or controversial which means it is for a much narrower audience.

One of the best things about attending Google's Energy Summit is I have now a deeper understanding of how things work.  The process that people can't see in the challenge of communicating green initiatives.  Just because something is invisible doesn't mean it is not important.

Yet, sometimes things need to be invisible in order to allow people to understand and not get distracted.  Here is a classic saying for Typography.  

Good typography is invisible. According to Gerard Unger: ” It is almost impossible to look
and read at the same time: they are different actions ” Therefore,
graphic designers, make your typography invisible so the words and messages can
communicate as intended.

 

Bad Typography is Everywhere / Good Typography is Invisible


NewImage

 

Full Media Coverage of Google's "How Green is the Internet?" event

I attended as media/press the 3rd Google Energy Summit.  I had been to the 1st, and was briefed on the presentations for the 2nd.  The third didn't focus on data centers as much and more asking questions and presenting data on the environmental impact of data centers and internet technologies.  Urs Hoelzle has been the executive sponsor for each one of these events.  Al Gore and Eric Schmidt for the first time presented their perspectives.

On purpose I choose not to write, tweet, during the summit.  There were a bunch of photographers and videographers there so I know the images and video are going to come.

NewImage

NewImage

It's a lot of hard work to record the content, let alone listen to what people are saying.

NewImage

Here are the list of news articles on the Google event that Google news shows.

Full coverage

Al Gore, Google search for a greener Internet

GreenBiz.com (blog) - ‎22 hours ago‎
How green is the Internet? Al Gore, Eric Schmidt and other experts packed a room at Google headquarters Thursday to explore the Internet's environmental impacts. With a crowd of about 100 people, it was the third event Google has hosted on this topic since ...
 

The internet is good for the planet, and let's keep it that way

GigaOM - ‎18 hours ago‎
But all of this research is so new, and these issues are so complex, that answering that question — is the internet green or not? — is a very difficult one. After the day long Google event called How green is the internet? I have a lot more questions than answers ...
 

Google Says: Save Energy, Ditch Your Data Center

Forbes - ‎Jun 6, 2013‎
Server and data center under-utilization is one of the primary sources of waste and inefficiency in computing, argued Hoelzle, who served as the master of ceremonies at the “How Green is the Internet?” symposium that took place at Google headquarters in ...
 

Is the Internet green? Yes and no

San Francisco Chronicle (blog) - ‎Jun 6, 2013‎
Google is hosting a summit on its corporate campus on Thursday exploring the question: How green is the Internet? The main speakers include former Vice President Al Gore, Google Chairman Eric Schmidt and Urs Hölzle, the Mountain View Internet giant's ...
 

The Efficiency Gap: Can Server Huggers Shift to the Cloud?

Data Center Knowledge - ‎Jun 7, 2013‎
That was the bottom line in a wide-ranging discussion Thursday at “How Green is the Internet,” a conference convened by Google to brainstorm ways to reduce the impact of Internet technology on the emission of green house gases. Data centers got their ...
 

Highlights from Google's Internet Summit

Data Center Knowledge - ‎Jun 7, 2013‎
At yesterday's “How Green is the Internet?” conference, Google Chairman Eric Schmidt shared anecdotes about the benefits of Internet services in the emerging world, citing his experiences in travels to Pakistan, southern Sudan and China. (Photo: Rich Miller).
 

Al Gore: Stop using the atmosphere as 'AN OPEN SEWER'

Register - ‎Jun 7, 2013‎
Speaking at Google's "How Green Is the Internet? Summit" at the company's Mountain View headquarters on Thursday, Gore reiterated his belief that global warming is real, and that its effects are already upon us. Gore's presentation at the gathering, which is ...
 

Al Gore: The information explosion is a tool to help solve the climate crisis

GigaOM - ‎Jun 6, 2013‎
The digital revolution and the explosion of data are powerful tools that can help solve the climate crisis, said Vice President Al Gore at Google's 'How Green is the Internet?' on Thursday. In Gore's talk he applauded the leadership roles that tech companies like ...
 
 

Amazon's Cloud coming to a country near you, mini-me AWS instances is inevitable

A friend asked me a month or so what is the next thing Amazon Web Services is going to do. I spent a bit of time researching ideas, then it hit me AWS will eventually be in major markets within the countries borders.

A couple of months ago I was chatting with a journalist from Spain and we discussed the cloud, hosting, and AWS.  Here is a post that ail give you an idea of the protectionist practices in Spain.

Hedge funds and private equity groups have raised concerns about the risk of creeping protectionism in proposals made by Spanish diplomats to re-write European Union legislation to regulate their industries for the first time.

He believed that a threat to IT jobs by moving to a public cloud outside the country would be met with protectionist enthusiasm to keep jobs in the high paying IT industry.

The cloud is a disruptive force that will challenge current IT operations, bringing automated standardized environments that require a small fraction of IT hardware and staff.  Requiring nationalized citizens to operate the IT environment is an easy impediment for moving to a cloud in another country in the USA or other places that are the cloud hubs.  This still leaves opportunities for the hosting companies in the country to provide IT services within the borders.

Now imagine this.  AWS gets 200kW of colocation space.  Ships in 4 cabinets of optimized cloud gear with room for another 16.  Ships the bits uninstalled on storage.  Has nationalized citizens run scripts that create the environment.  And launch a country specific AWS instance.  Local sales force drive sales and gets feedback on what needs to be added to remove barriers for companies to move into AWS.

What in this seems like it hard for AWS to do?

AWS's price point would be substantially lower than the local hosting company.  It is kind of like the infamous Wal-mart effect for retailers unable to compete with the low prices and selection.  Amazon.com can apply the same to hosted IT services in a country.

An example of markets that AWS mini-me could go are the locations that have edge locations.



EU (Ireland) Region

EC2 Availability Zones: 3    Launched 2007

AWS Edge Locations

  • Amsterdam,
    The Netherlands (2)
  • Dublin, Ireland
  • Frankfurt,
    Germany (2)
  • London, England (2)
  • Madrid, Spain
  • Milan, Italy
  • Paris, France (2)
  • Stockholm, Sweden



 

 

 

 

I have tested this idea on over 2 dozen people and they all say this makes total sense.

And GigaOm's Barb Darrow has shared the idea with the rest of the industry.

Coming from Amazon — lots of Mini-Me clouds for government work?

JUN. 6, 2013 - 10:29 AM PDT

3 Comments

Getty Images
photo: Getty Images
SUMMARY:

Amazon’s GovCloud targets U.S. state, federal and local government workloads. Here’s betting AWS will replicate that model abroad.

With my opinion added.

Right now, I should note that AWS had no comment on this story which is, after all largely speculation. But others who know data center technology and customer requirements agree this game plan makes sense. “There are lots of government workloads out there that require special handling — to protect citizen information etc. There’s a market for this,” said David Ohara, GigaOM Pro analyst and founder of Greenm3.

A journey through 10 data center conferences

I frequently get asked what data center conference to go to.  That is a tough question, because it depends on the person's objective.  Are they an end user looking on how to get up to speed?  Are they a vendor looking for customers?  Are they looking to add to their knowledge by learning new things?  I am going to share a journey through 10 data center conference that may give you some insight, but keep in mind my objective is different than most.  My goal is to hang with friends who are the A team players and learn as much as I can from attending.  Also, I get media passes for most of the events so my assessments are based on attending as media, not as a vendor or end user.

Saying I want to hang with the A team players can come off as arrogant and elitist, but I am used to hanging with really smart people when I was at HP, Apple, and Microsoft so it is a habit that is hard to break.  If you want to improve your game you want to be around the top players.  As an example, I was chatting with Jonathan Koomey yesterday and I was asking if he has gotten back into his Aikido training.  He had taken a break and I have taken one too.  Jonathan trained at Berkeley Aikikai.  I trained at Aikido of SJ.  Both dojos have 6th degree black belt senseis/teachers with high level students.  Many of the friends who started at the same time are Nidan, Sandan, Yondan (2nd, 3rd, 4th degree black belts).  I moved to Seattle 21 years ago, and unfortunately I still feel most comfortable training at my old dojo in SJ which means I have gone for so long I can't remember the last time I trained.  Jonathan has a shorter commute driving from Burlingame to Berkeley to go to his old dojo. I could train in the Seattle area, but I am so used to training with Aikidoists that I have known for quite a while it's just not that enjoyable training where there are not a lot of senior students. 

Finding a data center conference is kind of like finding an Aikido Dojo to train at.  Observing the senior students, the amount of A players at an event will help you give an idea of what it would be like to attend long term.

Observe students carefully, especially the seniors

When you walk into a dojo for a visit and observe training, I would recommend that you pay particular attention to the conduct of the senior students. These people have been training for lengthy periods, and their attitude, skill level, and level of conditioning will give a good indication of what you might expect to achieve after spending several years training.

Back to the 10 data center journey.

1. My data center conference journey started with Uptime Symposium 5 years ago spending a lot of time with Mike Manos, Christian Belady, and meeting a lot of the people who they knew. That jump started my data center conference experience.  I continued to go to Uptime Symposium for three years, but have stopped attending as I don't qualify for a media pass as I am not full-time media.  Do I need to attend Uptime Symposium to learn?  No, because I have access to the data center executives through my blog.  5 years ago it was useful, but I find I don't need to go to Uptime.  Someone could say that i should see the analysts presentations, but it is not worth $1,500 for me to learn how they explain something that I almost always know already.

2. In the early days of The Green Grid I would go to a few meetings to hear what is up with their standards.  I don't have a media pass, and it is not worth paying $5,000 a year to get an early disclosure of their specifications.   It has been said that The Green Grid is a good networking event, but I doubt I am going to meet somebody new that is worth $5,000 plus T&E to get to conferences.  I cannot say whether The Green Grid is worth attending for a person new to data centers as I haven't gone to a meeting for over 3 years.  If your goal is to have input on The Green Grid specifications then you should definitely consider going.

3. DatacenterDynamics I have attend in SF, Seattle, London and New York.  I find DCD is convenient for those who want a one day event close to the city they are located.  I attend DCD Seattle on an annual basis.

4. I've gone to Gartner Data Center Conference a couple of times and I find it is a good event for those who live by the Gartner gospel.  If you are a user who believes Gartner is your path of learning, then going to Gartner Data Center Conference makes sense.  One thing I did find is the A team doesn't go to Gartner, so I have passed on the event for the last few years.

5. Green Data Center Conference I haven't attended.  I requested a media pass a couple of years ago and they denied my request.  They have since offered a media pass, but I haven't found any of my friends recommend attending.

6. AFCOM Data Center World I have gone to a couple of times and if your goal is to meet other vendors then it is an event to consider as it has the widest range of data center vendors.  If you are a small - midsize end user looking for vendors then it is a good event.  On the other hand the A team players don't attend as they have no shortage of vendor contacts who are ready to make a visit to them.

7. Google Energy Summit I have gone to the 2009 event, was invited to the 2011 but couldn't attend, and just went to 2013 event.  This is an invitation only event.  Many of the leading people in data center industry attend as well as a broader range of environmental executives.  If you do get an invite I would highly recommend attending.

8. For an Enterprise customer base I have gone to IBM Pulse and Impact.  I find these useful to have discussions with IBM executives which I have access to through a media pass.  I don't attend many of the IBM events, but I find them useful to get insight into what is going on with the Enterprise users.  FYI, most of my time is spent with the Web2.0 type of companies.  Lately the Web2.0 methodologies have been adopted by the bigger enterprises and is part of IBM's product offerings.

9. Open Compute Summits I have enjoyed and gone to every one of them in Palo Alto, New York, San Antonio, and Santa Clara.  Open Compute is geared towards the Web 2.0 technical decision makers for low cost infrastructure built on open source ideas.  While some of the above conferences have slowed in growth or declined, Open Compute continues to attract more users every conference.  There is a nice mix of thought leaders and people who want to learn how to build from the Open Compute Project's open sourcing of data center technologies.

10. Part of what affects my attendance to the above events is that I find going to 7x24 Exchange conferences twice a year gets me out talking to friends often enough, once every 6 months.  I can get access to the speakers before and after to chat about the presentations that I am interested writing blog posts.  7x24 Exchange currently has the right mix I am looking for presentations, end users, vendors, and good friends.

Over time I have gotten to know more of the executives and staff at 7x24 Exchange, DCD, Google Energy Summit, and Open Compute Summit which makes it even easier for me to write blog posts and have interesting discussions. 

I was extremely lucky to start my data center conference journey with Mike Manos and Christian Belady's help, and I hope this post helps you to figure out what data center conference you want to attend.

oops, 30 mil servers connected to Internet, not 30 thousand (humor)

Sometimes a typo can get you to laugh.  I was reading DCK Rich Miller's post on the Google How Green is Internet? Event.

And I saw that there are 30,000 servers connected to the Internet.

google-koomey

Jon Koomey,a research fellow at Stanford University, says there are at least 1.6 billion devices connected to the Internet, including approximately 30,000 servers. (Photo: Rich Miller)

Rich Miller's reporting is so impeccable it is funny to see an oops moment.